NFL 2026 · Wk 11

Head coach · NYG 2016–2017

Ben McAdoo

Every game Ben McAdoo has coached since 1999: season by season, in the playoffs, against the spread and against every head coach faced. Fourth-down grades ↓

Share

Regular season
13–15
.464
Playoffs
0–1
1 playoff season
Against the spread
14–14
50% covered · 1 push
Wins vs. expected
+1.0
from points scored and allowed

Season by season 2016–2017

Regular season, with the playoff run beside it.

How to read

Ranks are the whole team's season among all teams; a season split between two coaches says how many games this one coached. Team codes are today's (the 2005 Chargers show as LAC).

SeasonTeamRecordWin %PointsPtsAllowedAllowedvs. expectedPlayoffsATS
2017NYG2–10 12 of 16 games.16731st27th−1.2–5–7
2016NYG11–5.68826th2nd+2.2Lost wild card 0–19–6–1

Record by situation

Every game, playoffs included unless the row says otherwise.

How to read

Favorite and underdog by the closing line; prime time by kickoff; temperature is the kickoff reading, outdoor games only.

GamesRecordWin %ATS
Regular season13–15.46414–13–1
Playoffs0–1.0000–1
Home8–5.6156–7
Road4–11.2677–7–1
Neutral site1–01.0001–0
As the favorite7–4.6365–6
As the underdog6–12.3339–8–1
One-score games (8 points or fewer)9–7.56310–5–1
Division games4–5.4445–4
vs. teams .500 or better6–11.3537–9–1
Prime time (7 p.m. ET or later)3–6.3333–5–1
Off a bye (13+ days' rest)1–1.5001–1
Short week (5 or fewer days' rest)0–2.0000–2
Cold (40°F or colder, outdoors)1–3.2501–3

Starting quarterbacks

Starts under this coach, playoffs included.

QuarterbackSeasonsStartsRecord
Eli ManningE. Manning2016–20172813–15
Geno SmithG. Smith201710–1

How the team played 2016–2017

From the play-by-play of every game this coach led, playoffs included.

How to read

Play calling belongs to the whole staff, and coordinators aren't in our data, so read these as the team's numbers under this head coach. Pass rate vs. expected counts 1st and 2nd downs in neutral game script. League averages this season: 7% no-huddle, 62% shotgun.

SeasonTeamOffense EPA/playOff EPADefense EPA/playDef EPAPass rate vs. exp.Pass vs. exp.No-huddleShotgun2-pt triesChallenges wonChallengesComeback / blownComeback / blown2nd-half margin
2017NYG−0.107 26th+0.010 24th+0.1%19%61%30 of 10 / 0−4.9
2016NYG−0.074 27th−0.085 5th+2.4%59%73%11 of 30 / 0+1.0
Career−0.087−0.046+1.5%43%68%41 of 40 / 0−1.4

Against every head coach

Ben McAdoo's record against each head coach on the other sideline, most meetings first. A name with two or more meetings opens that head-to-head page.

CoachGamesRecordWin %Playoff meetingsPlayoffsLast met
Jason GarrettJ. Garrett32–1.66702017
Jay GrudenJ. Gruden31–2.33302017
Doug PedersonD. Pederson31–2.33302017
Jim CaldwellJ. Caldwell21–1.50002017
Mike McCarthyM. McCarthy20–2.00012016
Dirk KoetterD. Koetter10–1.00002017
Anthony LynnA. Lynn10–1.00002017
Vance JosephV. Joseph11–01.00002017
Pete CarrollP. Carroll10–1.00002017
Sean McVayS. McVay10–1.00002017
Kyle ShanahanK. Shanahan10–1.00002017
Andy ReidA. Reid11–01.00002017
Jack Del RioJ. Del Rio10–1.00002017
Sean PaytonS. Payton11–01.00002016
Mike ZimmerM. Zimmer10–1.00002016
John HarbaughJ. Harbaugh11–01.00002016
Jeff FisherJ. Fisher11–01.00002016
Marvin LewisM. Lewis11–01.00002016
John FoxJ. Fox11–01.00002016
Hue JacksonH. Jackson11–01.00002016
Mike TomlinM. Tomlin10–1.00002016

Fourth-down decisions

Grade: the share of coach-seasons since 2010 that gave away more win probability per game (every season is blended with about 24 games of league-average play first, so a season only a few games old sits near 50).

How to read

How the grades work Every coach graded →

Career rank
–
ranked from 48 graded games (29 so far)
Win prob. lost per game
5.5 pp
win probability given away on 4th downs
Went when right
42%
13 of 31 clear go calls
Calls graded
241
29 games
SeasonTeamGamesCallsWent when rightWent when wrongCostly callsWin prob. lost / gameGrade
2017NYG129742% 5 of 121105.6 pp10 29th of 33
2016NYG1714442% 8 of 190135.4 pp9 30th of 34

Costliest calls

The calls that gave away the most win probability.

Win chance by option: G go for it · F field goal · P punt · K kick the extra point · 2 go for two. best call · the call made · win chance given away.

GameWhenSituationCallModelWin chance by optionWin % lost
2016 Wk 1 NYG v DALQ4 01:12Q4 01:12 · 4th & 1, opp 37, up 1PuntGo for itGFP12.6 pp
2017 Wk 3 NYG v PHIQ4 00:19Q4 00:19 · 4th & 1, own 34, tiedPuntGo for itGP9.1 pp
2016 Wk 10 NYG v CINQ4 06:23Q4 06:23 · 4th & 3, opp 46, up 1PuntGo for itGFP7.3 pp
2016 Wk 2 NYG v NOQ4 08:49Q4 08:49 · 4th & 1, opp 1, tiedField goal madeGo for itGF6.9 pp
2017 Wk 11 NYG v KCQ3 01:41Q3 01:41 · 4th & 9, opp 33, up 3Go for it failedField goalGFP4.1 pp
2017 Wk 7 NYG v SEAQ2 02:56Q2 02:56 · 4th & 1, own 23, up 7PuntGo for itGP3.7 pp
2017 Wk 4 NYG v TBQ4 09:32Q4 09:32 · 4th & 3, own 42, up 1PuntGo for itGP3.6 pp
2016 Wk 12 NYG v CLEQ2 12:18Q2 12:18 · 4th & 1, opp 47, tiedPuntGo for itGFP3.4 pp

Boldest right calls

Went for it where going was the best option by the widest margin.

GameWhenSituationCallModelWin chance by optionWin % lost
2016 Wk 6 NYG v BALQ4 01:36Q4 01:36 · 4th & 1, own 34, down 3Go for it convertedGo for itGP✓
2017 Wk 5 NYG v LACQ4 00:49Q4 00:49 · 4th & 10, opp 48, down 5Go for it failedGo for itGFP✓
2016 Wk 16 NYG v PHIQ4 02:00Q4 02:00 · 4th & 6, opp 37, down 5Go for it failedGo for itGFP✓
2017 Wk 3 NYG v PHIQ2 00:24Q2 00:24 · 4th & 1, opp 1, down 7Go for it failedGo for itGF✓
2016 Wk 11 NYG v CHIQ2 04:21Q2 04:21 · 4th & 2, opp 33, down 10Go for it convertedGo for itGFP✓
2016 Wk 10 NYG v CINQ4 14:12Q4 14:12 · 4th & 3, opp 3, down 6Go for it convertedGo for itGF✓