NFL 2026 · Wk 11

Head coaches · Analytics

Coaching decisions

Every 4th down since 2010, and every 4th-quarter try after a touchdown, scored by win probability: the chance of winning with each option, against the call the coach made. The grade is how little win probability a coach gives away per game, compared with every coach-season since 2010.

Stats through Week 10 and part of Week 11updated Sat 8:20 pm ET

Share

Grades as of

Head coaches 2026 season to date

Sorted by this season's grade. Grades are 0–100: the share of coach-seasons since 2010 that gave away more win probability per game on 4th downs.

How to read

One game's calls say little (most of the gap between two coaches in a game is luck of the situations), so every season is blended with 24 games of league-average play before it is ranked: early-season grades sit near 50 and only a long run of calls moves a coach to the ends.

CoachTeam2026 record2026 gradeCallsWent when rightWin prob. lost / game2025 grade2025 went when right2025 win prob. lost / gameCareer rank
Matt LaFleurM. LaFleurGB6-4976583% 5 of 61.0 pp8563%2.6 pp2nd of 73
Joe BradyJ. BradyBUF8-1925578% 7 of 91.5 pp–––new
Todd BowlesT. BowlesTB3-6916783% 5 of 61.5 pp7473%2.9 pp39th of 73
Klint KubiakK. KubiakLV4-6856275% 6 of 82.0 pp–––new
Todd MonkenT. MonkenCLE6-4808163% 5 of 82.3 pp–––new
Nick SirianniN. SirianniPHI2-7746960% 3 of 52.5 pp9370%2.2 pp3rd of 73
Ben JohnsonB. JohnsonCHI7-2725673% 8 of 112.5 pp5875%3.4 ppnew
Dan CampbellD. CampbellDET7-2725983% 5 of 62.5 pp9576%2.1 pp4th of 73
Mike VrabelM. VrabelNE5-5705669% 9 of 132.7 pp9671%2.2 pp15th of 73
Sean McVayS. McVayLA6-4676144% 4 of 92.8 pp8272%2.8 pp34th of 73
Dave CanalesD. CanalesCAR4-5676754% 7 of 132.8 pp6467%3.2 ppnew
Kellen MooreK. MooreNO3-6676664% 9 of 142.8 pp8374%2.6 ppnew
Robert SalehR. SalehTEN1-8656133% 3 of 92.9 pp–––27th of 73
DeMeco RyansD. RyansHOU4-6636840% 4 of 103.0 pp940%5.2 pp42nd of 73
Kevin StefanskiK. StefanskiATL3-7606240% 2 of 53.2 pp3165%4.2 pp10th of 73
Kyle ShanahanK. ShanahanSF8-1604157% 4 of 73.1 pp7356%3.0 pp11th of 73
Brian SchottenheimerB. SchottenheimerDAL4-6607057% 8 of 143.2 pp9977%1.6 ppnew
Kevin O'ConnellK. O'ConnellMIN7-2597150% 5 of 103.2 pp5453%3.5 pp22nd of 73
Liam CoenL. CoenJAX7-2584556% 5 of 93.3 pp9268%2.3 ppnew
Andy ReidA. ReidKC7-2565469% 9 of 133.3 pp5270%3.6 pp26th of 73
Zac TaylorZ. TaylorCIN7-2534443% 3 of 73.4 pp5961%3.4 pp12th of 73
Mike McCarthyM. McCarthyPIT6-3476350% 3 of 63.7 pp–––24th of 73
John HarbaughJ. HarbaughNYG5-3-1446845% 5 of 113.8 pp7656%2.9 pp29th of 73
Jeff HafleyJ. HafleyMIA1-8395680% 4 of 54.0 pp–––new
Mike LaFleurM. LaFleurARI3-7397750% 7 of 144.0 pp–––new
Jesse MinterJ. MinterBAL4-6366638% 5 of 134.1 pp–––new
Aaron GlennA. GlennNYJ2-8357450% 7 of 144.2 pp6762%3.1 ppnew
Mike MacdonaldM. MacdonaldSEA6-4316731% 4 of 134.4 pp9033%2.5 ppnew
Sean PaytonS. PaytonDEN7-2276925% 3 of 124.7 pp4753%3.7 pp41st of 73
Dan QuinnD. QuinnWAS3-5-1227246% 6 of 135.0 pp7956%2.7 pp32nd of 73
Jim HarbaughJ. HarbaughLAC1-8226425% 2 of 85.0 pp3024%4.2 pp55th of 73
Shane SteichenS. SteichenIND3-8117647% 9 of 195.7 pp9371%2.2 pp36th of 73

The league learned to go for it

Share of 4th downs where going was clearly the better call that teams actually went for it, by season. 2026 is the season so far.

0%20%40%60%20102012201420162018202020222024202653%
0%20%40%60%20102013201620192022202553%

And stopped giving games away

Win probability lost per team-game on 4th-down calls, in percentage points (pp), by season. 2026 is the season so far.

0.0 pp1.0 pp2.0 pp3.0 pp4.0 pp5.0 pp2010201220142016201820202022202420263.3 pp
0.0 pp1.0 pp2.0 pp3.0 pp4.0 pp5.0 pp2010201320162019202220253.3 pp

All-time, since 2010

Head coaches with at least 48 graded games (about three seasons) of games, ranked by win probability lost per game on 4th downs (lower is better).

How to read

Earlier eras were more conservative, so long careers that started before 2018 carry that cost.

#CoachSeasonsGamesCallsWent when rightWin prob. lost / game
1Jonathan GannonJ. Gannon2023–20255131262%2.2 pp
2Matt LaFleurM. LaFleur2019–202613677862%2.3 pp
3Nick SirianniN. Sirianni2021–202610465463%2.5 pp
4Dan CampbellD. Campbell2021–20269860972%2.5 pp
5Sean McDermottS. McDermott2017–202516496459%2.6 pp
6Kliff KingsburyK. Kingsbury2019–20226744065%2.7 pp
7Arthur SmithA. Smith2021–20235134357%2.7 pp
8Brian FloresB. Flores2019–20214931741%2.8 pp
9Mike McDanielM. McDaniel2022–20257042553%2.9 pp
10Kevin StefanskiK. Stefanski2020–202611480466%2.9 pp
11Kyle ShanahanK. Shanahan2017–202617295745%3.1 pp
12Zac TaylorZ. Taylor2019–202613280450%3.2 pp
13Frank ReichF. Reich2018–20238857364%3.2 pp
14Matt NagyM. Nagy2018–20216745254%3.2 pp
15Mike VrabelM. Vrabel2018–202613584849%3.2 pp
16Jon GrudenJ. Gruden2018–20215333760%3.3 pp
17Norv TurnerN. Turner2010–20124827534%3.3 pp
18Brandon StaleyB. Staley2021–20234934662%3.3 pp
19Adam GaseA. Gase2016–20208152736%3.3 pp
20Matt EberflusM. Eberflus2022–20245135256%3.3 pp
21Leslie FrazierL. Frazier2010–20135537038%3.3 pp
22Kevin O'ConnellK. O'Connell2022–20267952749%3.3 pp
23Dirk KoetterD. Koetter2016–20184829630%3.4 pp
24Mike McCarthyM. McCarthy2010–20262521,54142%3.4 pp
25Doug PedersonD. Pederson2016–202413993953%3.4 pp
26Andy ReidA. Reid2010–20262971,82948%3.4 pp
27Robert SalehR. Saleh2021–20267756344%3.4 pp
28Mike ZimmerM. Zimmer2014–202113486839%3.5 pp
29John HarbaughJ. Harbaugh2010–20262891,90947%3.5 pp
30Gus BradleyG. Bradley2013–20166244631%3.5 pp
31Ron RiveraR. Rivera2011–20232191,43546%3.5 pp
32Dan QuinnD. Quinn2015–202613684051%3.5 pp
33Raheem MorrisR. Morris2010–20257751153%3.6 pp
34Sean McVayS. McVay2017–20261751,09145%3.6 pp
35Chan GaileyC. Gailey2010–20124830438%3.6 pp
36Shane SteichenS. Steichen2023–20266242760%3.6 pp
37Chip KellyC. Kelly2013–20166445437%3.6 pp
38Hue JacksonH. Jackson2011–20185639343%3.7 pp
39Todd BowlesT. Bowles2011–20261481,02344%3.7 pp
40Chuck PaganoC. Pagano2012–201710267234%3.8 pp
41Sean PaytonS. Payton2010–20262521,56142%3.8 pp
42DeMeco RyansD. Ryans2023–20266748440%3.8 pp
43Dennis AllenD. Allen2012–20248758736%3.8 pp
44Brian DabollB. Daboll2022–20257049356%3.9 pp
45Bill BelichickB. Belichick2010–20232511,49935%3.9 pp
46Joe PhilbinJ. Philbin2012–20186845831%3.9 pp
47Anthony LynnA. Lynn2016–20206741042%3.9 pp
48Jeff FisherJ. Fisher2010–20169665430%4.0 pp
49Jim CaldwellJ. Caldwell2010–20179966031%4.0 pp
50Jason GarrettJ. Garrett2010–20191571,00336%4.0 pp
51John FoxJ. Fox2010–201713584528%4.1 pp
52Bill O'BrienB. O'Brien2014–202010675837%4.1 pp
53Pete CarrollP. Carroll2010–20252631,74134%4.1 pp
54Jack Del RioJ. Del Rio2010–20177652938%4.1 pp
55Jim HarbaughJ. Harbaugh2011–202611779629%4.1 pp
56Lovie SmithL. Smith2010–20229964331%4.1 pp
57Vic FangioV. Fangio2019–20214933145%4.1 pp
58Tom CoughlinT. Coughlin2010–201510066831%4.2 pp
59Pat ShurmurP. Shurmur2011–20196547041%4.2 pp
60Bruce AriansB. Arians2013–202113888528%4.2 pp
61Mike TomlinM. Tomlin2010–20252771,86835%4.3 pp
62Jay GrudenJ. Gruden2014–20198656329%4.3 pp
63Mike McCoyM. McCoy2013–20166642034%4.3 pp
64Mike ShanahanM. Shanahan2010–20136546340%4.3 pp
65Mike SmithM. Smith2010–20148452024%4.5 pp
66Ken WhisenhuntK. Whisenhunt2010–20158058326%4.5 pp
67Doug MarroneD. Marrone2013–202010172926%4.5 pp
68Marvin LewisM. Lewis2010–20181491,01733%4.5 pp
69Jim SchwartzJ. Schwartz2010–20136547235%4.6 pp
70Rex RyanR. Ryan2010–201611480227%4.7 pp
71Mike MunchakM. Munchak2011–20134834536%4.7 pp
72Mike MularkeyM. Mularkey2012–20175035027%4.8 pp
73Gary KubiakG. Kubiak2010–201610074128%5.1 pp

How the grades work

  • Win probability. A model trained on every play since 2010 reproduces nflfastR's win probability for any situation, including the ones a coach did not choose.
  • Options. Going for it uses the chance of converting at that distance and spot, and where a conversion usually leaves the ball; a field goal uses the make rate at that distance; a punt uses where punts from that spot usually leave the other team.
  • Tries after touchdowns. Kick or go for two is scored with a possession model: the other team receives, possessions alternate until time runs out, and each scores at the league's current touchdown and field-goal rates. It reproduces the classic two-point chart's clear cases with today's scoring. Tries are graded in the 4th quarter, where they matter.
  • Each team's roster. The pregame spread tells the model how good each team is overall. On top of that, the chance of converting reflects that offense against that defense, and win probability reflects how each side's strength splits between offense and defense (with a strong defense, giving the ball back costs less). Both use only games played before the call. They change the best call on about 4% of 4th downs.
  • Cost. The best option's win probability minus the chosen one's. Calls within about one point of win probability are toss-ups and cost almost nothing.
  • Not graded. Overtime (different rules) and games already decided.