NFL 2026 · Wk 11

Draft grades · 2010–2024

Buffalo Bills draft grades

Every Bills pick since 2010: what each became against what picks in the same slot became in the same draft, class by class.

Share

Since 2010
#9 · B
+153.3 value above slot, rank of 32
Best class
2018 · A
+137.5, led by Josh Allen
Pro Bowlers drafted
12
38 started 3+ seasons
Value kept
69%
of their picks' careers, earned for the Bills

Class by class Drafts 2010–2026

Each class graded against the same draft's 32 classes once it has had two full seasons.

How to read

Value counts the players' whole careers, wherever they played.

DraftGradeRankPicksCareer valueValueSlots expectExp.Above slot+/-Pro BowlersBest value pick
2026–too early100––0–
2025–too early91618.6−2.60Deone Walker Rd 4 · #109
2024C14th104339.9+3.10Ray Davis Rd 4 · #128
2023B8th65744.2+12.81O'Cyrus Torrence Rd 2 · #59
2022A1st813173.9+57.11James Cook Rd 2 · #63
2021B8th89675.3+20.70Spencer Brown Rd 3 · #93
2020B11th79671.5+24.50Gabe Davis Rd 4 · #128
2019C14th8139130.0+9.01Devin Singletary Rd 3 · #74
2018A2nd8304166.5+137.53Josh Allen Rd 1 · #7
2017A2nd6218118.9+99.13Dion Dawkins Rd 2 · #63
2016F28th766134.1−68.10–
2015C17th67673.3+2.70John Miller Rd 3 · #81
2014D22nd7121141.0−20.00Preston Brown Rd 3 · #73
2013C15th8159151.8+7.20Robert Woods Rd 2 · #41
2012C15th9175177.5−2.51Stephon Gilmore Rd 1 · #10
2011D26th9146182.0−36.01Da'Norris Searcy Rd 4 · #100
2010F32nd968161.8−93.81Arthur Moats Rd 6 · #178

Every pick since 2010 Since 2010

Newest draft first. Every column sorts.

DraftPickPlayerPosCollegeValueSlot+/−KeptGamesStarter yrsPro Bowls
2026Rd 2 · #35T.J. ParkerDEClemson0––0900
2026Rd 2 · #62Davison IgbinosunCBOhio St.0––0900
2026Rd 4 · #102Jude BowryOTBoston Col.0––0200
2026Rd 4 · #125Skyler BellWRConnecticut0––0300
2026Rd 4 · #126Kaleb Elarms-OrrLBTCU0––0900
2026Rd 5 · #167Jalon KilgoreCBSouth Carolina0––0200
2026Rd 5 · #181Zane DurantDTPenn St.0––0000
2026Rd 7 · #220Toriano PrideCBMissouri0––0800
2026Rd 7 · #239Tommy DomanPFlorida0––0900
2026Rd 7 · #241Ar'maj Reed-AdamsGTexas A&M0––0100
2025Rd 1 · #30Maxwell HairstonCBKentucky24.4−2.422000
2025Rd 2 · #41T.J. SandersDTSouth Carolina23.9−1.921700
2025Rd 3 · #72Landon JacksonDEArkansas02.9−2.901100
2025Rd 4 · #109Deone WalkerDTKentucky82.1+5.982610
2025Rd 5 · #170Jordan HancockSAFOhio St.11.3−0.311600
2025Rd 5 · #173Jackson HawesTEGeorgia Tech21.3+0.722600
2025Rd 6 · #177Dorian StrongCBVirginia Tech11.2−0.21400
2025Rd 6 · #206Chase LundtOLConnecticut00.9−0.90200
2025Rd 7 · #240Kaden PratherWRMaryland00.6−0.60000
2024Rd 2 · #33Keon ColemanWRFlorida St.119.1+1.9113510
2024Rd 2 · #60Cole BishopSAFUtah96.9+2.194210
2024Rd 3 · #95DeWayne CarterDTDuke25.1−3.122000
2024Rd 4 · #128Ray DavisRBKentucky104.0+6.0104300
2024Rd 5 · #141Sedrick Van Pran-GrangerOLGeorgia43.6+0.444000
2024Rd 5 · #160Edefuan UlofoshioLBWashington13.0−2.01500
2024Rd 5 · #168Javon SolomonDETroy42.8+1.244000
2024Rd 6 · #204Tylan GrableOLCentral Florida22.0+0.021200
2024Rd 6 · #219Daequan HardyCBPenn St.01.7−1.70000
2024Rd 7 · #221Travis ClaytonOT01.7−1.70000
2023Rd 1 · #25Dalton KincaidTEUtah1715.6+1.4175021
2023Rd 2 · #59O'Cyrus TorrenceOLFlorida2310.9+12.1236030
2023Rd 3 · #91Dorian WilliamsLBTulane138.3+4.7135920
2023Rd 5 · #150Justin ShorterWRFlorida05.2−5.201700
2023Rd 7 · #230Nick BroekerOLMississippi12.4−1.401200
2023Rd 7 · #252Alex AustinDBOregon St.31.8+1.202900
2022Rd 1 · #23Kaiir ElamCBFlorida922.2−13.264400
2022Rd 2 · #63James CookRBGeorgia4314.5+28.5437533
2022Rd 3 · #89Terrel BernardLBBaylor2511.6+13.4256730
2022Rd 5 · #148Khalil ShakirWRBoise St.257.3+17.7257130
2022Rd 6 · #180Matt AraizaPSan Diego St.55.5−0.504310
2022Rd 6 · #185Christian BenfordDBVillanova195.3+13.7196130
2022Rd 6 · #209Luke TenutaOLVirginia Tech04.2−4.201700
2022Rd 7 · #231Baylon SpectorLBClemson53.3+1.752900
2021Rd 1 · #30Gregory RousseauDLMiami (FL)3822.3+15.7388750
2021Rd 2 · #61Boogie BashamDLWake Forest416.2−12.234300
2021Rd 3 · #93Spencer BrownOLNorthern Iowa3812.4+25.6388140
2021Rd 5 · #161Tommy DoyleOLMiami (OH)17.2−6.211200
2021Rd 6 · #203Marquez StevensonWRHouston04.9−4.90500
2021Rd 6 · #212Damar HamlinDBPittsburgh114.5+6.5116220
2021Rd 6 · #213Rachad WildgooseCBWisconsin24.4−2.402000
2021Rd 7 · #236Jack AndersonOLTexas Tech23.4−1.401500
2020Rd 2 · #54A.J. EpenesaDEIowa1820.5−2.5189810
2020Rd 3 · #86Zack MossRBUtah1815.6+2.486110
2020Rd 4 · #128Gabe DavisWRCentral Florida2811.1+16.9268040
2020Rd 5 · #167Jake FrommQBGeorgia18.1−7.10300
2020Rd 6 · #188Tyler BassKGeorgia Southern136.7+6.3139220
2020Rd 6 · #207Isaiah HodginsWROregon St.65.6+0.403810
2020Rd 7 · #239Dane JacksonCBPittsburgh123.9+8.1126410
2019Rd 1 · #9Ed OliverDTHouston4341.0+2.04310150
2019Rd 2 · #38Cody FordTOklahoma2226.4−4.4139910
2019Rd 3 · #74Devin SingletaryRBFlorida Atlantic3918.8+20.22811650
2019Rd 3 · #96Dawson KnoxTEMississippi2515.7+9.32511171
2019Rd 5 · #147Vosean JosephLBFlorida010.5−10.50000
2019Rd 6 · #181Jaquan JohnsonCBMiami (FL)57.8−2.856000
2019Rd 7 · #225Darryl JohnsonDENorth Carolina A&T45.0−1.033800
2019Rd 7 · #228Tommy SweeneyTEBoston Col.14.8−3.812400
2018Rd 1 · #7Josh AllenQBWyoming11152.6+58.411113784
2018Rd 1 · #16Tremaine EdmundsILBVirginia Tech6243.1+18.94412582
2018Rd 3 · #96Harrison PhillipsDTStanford3519.1+15.9812340
2018Rd 4 · #121Taron JohnsonCBWeber St.3615.7+20.33612360
2018Rd 5 · #154Siran NealCBJacksonville St.712.0−5.0514000
2018Rd 5 · #166Wyatt TellerGVirginia Tech3910.9+28.1111773
2018Rd 6 · #187Ray-Ray McCloudWRClemson149.0+5.0010010
2018Rd 7 · #255Austin ProehlWRNorth Carolina04.1−4.10000
2017Rd 1 · #27Tre'Davious WhiteCBLSU5335.0+18.05210962
2017Rd 2 · #37Zay JonesWREast Carolina2531.1−6.1812430
2017Rd 2 · #63Dion DawkinsGTemple7324.1+48.97315195
2017Rd 5 · #163Matt MilanoLBBoston Col.5710.7+46.35710651
2017Rd 5 · #171Nathan PetermanQBPittsburgh310.0−7.021500
2017Rd 6 · #195Tanner VallejoLBBoise St.78.0−1.018200
2016Rd 1 · #19Shaq LawsonDEClemson2440.9−16.91511010
2016Rd 2 · #41Reggie RaglandILBAlabama2231.0−9.007930
2016Rd 3 · #80Adolphus WashingtonDTOhio St.921.7−12.793520
2016Rd 4 · #139Cardale JonesQBOhio St.013.5−13.50100
2016Rd 5 · #156Jonathan WilliamsRBArkansas511.8−6.814700
2016Rd 6 · #192Kolby ListenbeeWRTCU08.6−8.60000
2016Rd 6 · #218Kevon SeymourCBUSC66.6−0.616700
2015Rd 2 · #50Ronald DarbyCBFlorida St.3424.6+9.4911880
2015Rd 3 · #81John MillerGLouisville3118.7+12.3198750
2015Rd 5 · #155Karlos WilliamsRBFlorida St.410.3−6.341100
2015Rd 6 · #188Tony StewardOLBClemson17.7−6.71700
2015Rd 6 · #194Nick O'LearyTEFlorida St.67.3−1.345920
2015Rd 7 · #234Dezmin LewisWRCentral Arkansas04.7−4.70200
2014Rd 1 · #4Sammy WatkinsWRClemson4354.0−11.02011160
2014Rd 2 · #44Cyrus KouandjioTAlabama627.8−21.853000
2014Rd 3 · #73Preston BrownLBLouisville3421.3+12.7288160
2014Rd 4 · #109Ross CockrellDBDuke2015.9+4.109730
2014Rd 5 · #153Cyril RichardsonGBaylor211.2−9.221200
2014Rd 7 · #221Randell JohnsonLBFlorida Atlantic25.9−3.921600
2014Rd 7 · #237Seantrel HendersonOLMiami (FL)144.9+9.1133920
2013Rd 1 · #16EJ ManuelQBFlorida St.1037.9−27.9103010
2013Rd 2 · #41Robert WoodsWRUSC5927.3+31.715171100
2013Rd 2 · #46Kiko AlonsoLBOregon3325.9+7.1108640
2013Rd 3 · #78Marquise GoodwinWRTexas2419.4+4.6511430
2013Rd 4 · #105Duke WilliamsDBNevada815.6−7.685800
2013Rd 5 · #143Jonathan MeeksDBClemson211.5−9.523800
2013Rd 6 · #177Dustin HopkinsKFlorida St.228.7+13.3014010
2013Rd 7 · #222Chris GraggTEArkansas15.5−4.513200
2012Rd 1 · #10Stephon GilmoreDBSouth Carolina7548.9+26.118180125
2012Rd 2 · #41Cordy GlennGGeorgia3831.2+6.8319760
2012Rd 3 · #69T.J. GrahamWRNorth Carolina St.724.0−17.064710
2012Rd 4 · #105Nigel BradhamLBFlorida St.4417.9+26.11611670
2012Rd 4 · #124Ron BrooksDBLSU615.4−9.445300
2012Rd 5 · #144Zebrie SandersOLFlorida St.013.1−13.10000
2012Rd 5 · #147Tank CarderLBTCU512.8−7.807800
2012Rd 6 · #178Mark AsperGOregon09.8−9.80700
2012Rd 7 · #251John PotterKWestern Michigan04.4−4.40900
2011Rd 1 · #3Marcell DareusDTAlabama5658.8−2.84712172
2011Rd 2 · #34Aaron WilliamsDBTexas1732.1−15.1175940
2011Rd 3 · #68Kelvin SheppardLBLSU2523.1+1.9810740
2011Rd 4 · #100Da'Norris SearcyDBNorth Carolina2417.7+6.31210930
2011Rd 4 · #122Chris HairstonTClemson1714.9+2.187420
2011Rd 5 · #133Johnny WhiteRBNorth Carolina013.6−13.601900
2011Rd 6 · #169Chris WhiteLBMississippi St.310.1−7.115100
2011Rd 7 · #206Justin RogersDBRichmond47.2−3.243900
2011Rd 7 · #245Michael JasperDTBethel (TN)04.5−4.50000
2010Rd 1 · #9C.J. SpillerRBClemson3448.2−14.2329031
2010Rd 2 · #41Torell TroupDTCentral Florida230.0−28.022100
2010Rd 3 · #72Alex CarringtonDEArkansas St.722.5−15.565910
2010Rd 4 · #107Marcus EasleyWRConnecticut116.9−15.914200
2010Rd 5 · #140Ed WangTVirginia Tech013.0−13.00600
2010Rd 6 · #178Arthur MoatsLBJames Madison229.4+12.61012130
2010Rd 6 · #192Danny BattenDESouth Dakota St.28.3−6.321600
2010Rd 7 · #209Levi BrownQBTroy07.0−7.00100
2010Rd 7 · #216Kyle CallowayTIowa06.5−6.50000

How the grades work

Each player's value is Pro Football Reference's weighted career approximate value (AV), a single number for any position that counts a player's best seasons most. Each slot's expectation comes from one curve over the pick number, fitted to every draft since 2010 (an average pick = 1×: pick 1 3.8×, pick 10 2.6×, pick 32 1.9×, pick 64 1.3×, pick 100 1.0×, pick 200 0.4×), then scaled draft by draft to what that draft actually produced, so an older class isn't favored for having had more seasons. A class's score is its picks' value above or below their slots; the letter grades it against the same draft's 32 classes (A about the top sixth, F the bottom sixth).

Value counts the whole career wherever it was played; "Kept" is the share earned for the drafting team. Trades of picks are credited to the team that made the pick. Recent classes keep moving as careers go on.