NFL 2026 · Wk 11

Draft grades · 2010–2024

Carolina Panthers draft grades

Every Panthers pick since 2010: what each became against what picks in the same slot became in the same draft, class by class.

Share

Since 2010
#22 · C
−59.4 value above slot, rank of 32
Best class
2017 · B
+43.4, led by Christian McCaffrey
Pro Bowlers drafted
11
27 started 3+ seasons
Value kept
73%
of their picks' careers, earned for the Panthers

Class by class Drafts 2010–2026

Each class graded against the same draft's 32 classes once it has had two full seasons.

How to read

Value counts the players' whole careers, wherever they played.

DraftGradeRankPicksCareer valueValueSlots expectExp.Above slot+/-Pro BowlersBest value pick
2026–too early70––0–
2025–too early82320.7+2.30Tetairoa McMillan Rd 1 · #8
2024D25th72634.8−8.80Chau Smith-Wade Rd 5 · #157
2023F30th53764.3−27.30–
2022D27th63964.1−25.10Cade Mays Rd 6 · #199
2021F29th1187118.9−31.91Chuba Hubbard Rd 4 · #126
2020C19th7109116.0−7.01Jeremy Chinn Rd 2 · #64
2019F28th777110.9−33.91Brian Burns Rd 1 · #16
2018C15th8132140.1−8.10D.J. Moore Rd 1 · #24
2017B6th7193149.6+43.41Christian McCaffrey Rd 1 · #8
2016C19th582100.2−18.21James Bradberry Rd 2 · #62
2015B6th512593.4+31.60Daryl Williams Rd 4 · #102
2014C10th6123107.7+15.31Trai Turner Rd 3 · #92
2013B8th5130100.5+29.51A.J. Klein Rd 5 · #148
2012B10th7171145.4+25.62Luke Kuechly Rd 1 · #9
2011D21st8139164.1−25.11Cam Newton Rd 1 · #1
2010D19th10107126.4−19.41Greg Hardy Rd 6 · #175

Every pick since 2010 Since 2010

Newest draft first. Every column sorts.

DraftPickPlayerPosCollegeValueSlot+/−KeptGamesStarter yrsPro Bowls
2026Rd 1 · #19Monroe FreelingOTGeorgia0––0800
2026Rd 2 · #49Lee HunterDTTexas Tech0––0900
2026Rd 3 · #83Chris Brazzell IIWRTennessee0––0000
2026Rd 4 · #129Will LeeCBTexas A&M0––0700
2026Rd 5 · #144Sam HechtCKansas St.0––0700
2026Rd 5 · #151Zakee WheatleySPenn St.0––0800
2026Rd 7 · #227Jackson KuwatchLBMiami (OH)0––0900
2025Rd 1 · #8Tetairoa McMillanWRArizona96.4+2.692610
2025Rd 2 · #51Nic ScourtonDETexas A&M43.5+0.541700
2025Rd 3 · #77Princely UmanmielenDEMississippi22.8−0.822500
2025Rd 4 · #114Trevor EtienneRBGeorgia12.1−1.112200
2025Rd 4 · #122Lathan RansomSAFOhio St.31.9+1.132500
2025Rd 5 · #140Cam JacksonDTFlorida11.7−0.711000
2025Rd 5 · #163Mitchell EvansTENotre Dame21.4+0.622610
2025Rd 6 · #208Jimmy HornWRColorado10.9+0.111400
2024Rd 1 · #32Xavier LegetteWRSouth Carolina89.2−1.283420
2024Rd 2 · #46Jonathon BrooksRBTexas07.9−7.90500
2024Rd 3 · #72Trevin WallaceLBKentucky86.2+1.883120
2024Rd 4 · #101Ja'Tavion SandersTETexas54.9+0.153000
2024Rd 5 · #157Chau Smith-WadeDBWashington St.53.1+1.953800
2024Rd 6 · #200Jaden CrumedyDTMississippi St.02.1−2.101400
2024Rd 7 · #240Michael BarrettLBMichigan01.4−1.40000
2023Rd 1 · #1Bryce YoungQBAlabama2329.7−6.7235520
2023Rd 2 · #39Jonathan MingoWRMississippi413.2−9.244710
2023Rd 3 · #80DJ JohnsonOLBOregon39.1−6.133100
2023Rd 4 · #114Chandler ZavalaGNorth Carolina St.66.9−0.963500
2023Rd 5 · #145Jammie RobinsonDBFlorida St.15.4−4.413100
2022Rd 1 · #6Ikem EkwonuTNorth Carolina St.2531.3−6.3256440
2022Rd 3 · #94Matt CorralQBMississippi011.2−11.20000
2022Rd 4 · #120Brandon SmithLBPenn St.19.1−8.111400
2022Rd 6 · #189Amare BarnoDEVirginia Tech25.1−3.122900
2022Rd 6 · #199Cade MaysOLTennessee114.6+6.4115410
2022Rd 7 · #242Kalon BarnesCBBaylor02.8−2.80200
2021Rd 1 · #8Jaycee HornDBSouth Carolina2232.4−10.4225632
2021Rd 2 · #59Terrace Marshall Jr.WRLSU616.5−10.564310
2021Rd 3 · #70Brady ChristensenOLBYU1415.0−1.0145910
2021Rd 3 · #83Tommy TrembleTENotre Dame713.4−6.478720
2021Rd 4 · #126Chuba HubbardRBOklahoma St.279.5+17.5278820
2021Rd 5 · #158Daviyon NixonDTIowa17.4−6.411400
2021Rd 5 · #166Keith TaylorDBWashington56.9−1.944700
2021Rd 6 · #193Deonte BrownOLAlabama05.4−5.40300
2021Rd 6 · #204Shi SmithWRSouth Carolina44.8−0.842300
2021Rd 6 · #222Thomas FletcherLSAlabama04.0−4.00000
2021Rd 7 · #232Phil HoskinsDTKentucky13.6−2.601300
2020Rd 1 · #7Derrick BrownDTAuburn3539.6−4.6359351
2020Rd 2 · #38Yetur Gross-MatosDEPenn St.1824.1−6.1167410
2020Rd 2 · #64Jeremy ChinnSSouthern Illinois4118.7+22.3329650
2020Rd 4 · #113Troy Pride Jr.CBNotre Dame312.6−9.631700
2020Rd 5 · #152Kenny Robinson Jr.SWest Virginia19.2−8.211900
2020Rd 6 · #184Bravvion RoyDTBaylor97.0+2.094510
2020Rd 7 · #221Stantley Thomas-OliverCBFlorida International24.8−2.822600
2019Rd 1 · #16Brian BurnsDEFlorida St.5335.5+17.53411763
2019Rd 2 · #37Greg LittleTMississippi826.7−18.733100
2019Rd 3 · #100Will GrierQBWest Virginia115.2−14.21200
2019Rd 4 · #115Christian MillerLBAlabama113.5−12.51700
2019Rd 5 · #154Jordan ScarlettRBFlorida09.9−9.901000
2019Rd 6 · #212Dennis DaleyTSouth Carolina145.8+8.285420
2019Rd 7 · #237Terry GodwinWRGeorgia04.3−4.30300
2018Rd 1 · #24D.J. MooreWRMaryland6138.1+22.93613880
2018Rd 2 · #55Donte JacksonCBLSU3427.1+6.92311880
2018Rd 3 · #85Rashaan GauldenCBTennessee120.9−19.912700
2018Rd 4 · #101Ian ThomasTEIndiana818.4−10.4712430
2018Rd 4 · #136Marquis HaynesOLBMississippi713.9−6.977300
2018Rd 5 · #161Jermaine Carter Jr.LBMaryland1511.3+3.7147220
2018Rd 7 · #234Andre SmithILBNorth Carolina65.5+0.516200
2018Rd 7 · #242Kendrick NortonDTMiami (FL)04.9−4.90000
2017Rd 1 · #8Christian McCaffreyRBStanford8649.0+37.04312164
2017Rd 2 · #40Curtis SamuelWROhio St.3030.1−0.11711150
2017Rd 2 · #64Taylor MotonGWestern Michigan4723.9+23.14714780
2017Rd 3 · #77Daeshon HallDETexas A&M121.4−20.401300
2017Rd 5 · #152Corn ElderCBMiami (FL)211.7−9.723500
2017Rd 6 · #192Alex ArmahFBWest Georgia08.2−8.207800
2017Rd 7 · #233Harrison ButkerKGeorgia Tech275.3+21.7014630
2016Rd 1 · #30Vernon ButlerDTLouisiana Tech1335.1−22.187720
2016Rd 2 · #62James BradberryCBSamford4625.3+20.71612581
2016Rd 3 · #77Daryl WorleyCBWest Virginia2222.2−0.2119940
2016Rd 5 · #141Zack SanchezCBOklahoma113.3−12.31500
2016Rd 7 · #252Beau SandlandTEMontana St.04.3−4.30000
2015Rd 1 · #25Shaq ThompsonOLBWashington4332.6+10.44113580
2015Rd 2 · #41Devin FunchessWRMichigan2027.0−7.0206220
2015Rd 4 · #102Daryl WilliamsGOklahoma3915.8+23.2228950
2015Rd 5 · #169David MayoLBTexas St.189.2+8.8413210
2015Rd 5 · #174Cameron Artis-PayneRBAuburn58.8−3.853200
2014Rd 1 · #28Kelvin BenjaminWRFlorida St.2233.3−11.3186140
2014Rd 2 · #60Kony EalyDEMissouri1223.8−11.8106500
2014Rd 3 · #92Trai TurnerOLLSU5118.2+32.84112695
2014Rd 4 · #128Tre BostonDBNorth Carolina2813.7+14.31710440
2014Rd 5 · #148Bene BenwikereDBSan Jose St.1011.6−1.665410
2014Rd 6 · #204Tyler GaffneyRBStanford07.1−7.10000
2013Rd 1 · #14Star LotuleleiDTUtah4839.3+8.72811970
2013Rd 2 · #44Kawann ShortDTPurdue4126.5+14.5419952
2013Rd 4 · #108Edmund KugbilaOLValdosta St.015.3−15.30000
2013Rd 5 · #148A.J. KleinLBIowa St.3711.1+25.9914650
2013Rd 6 · #182Kenjon BarnerRBOregon48.3−4.307600
2012Rd 1 · #9Luke KuechlyLBBoston Col.9150.1+40.99111887
2012Rd 2 · #40Amini SilatoluGMidwestern St.1831.6−13.6185410
2012Rd 4 · #103Frank AlexanderDEOklahoma618.2−12.262900
2012Rd 4 · #104Joe AdamsWRArkansas018.0−18.00900
2012Rd 5 · #143Josh NormanDBCoastal Carolina4313.2+29.82214181
2012Rd 6 · #207Brad NortmanPWisconsin117.5+3.579600
2012Rd 7 · #216D.J. CampbellDBCalifornia26.8−4.82900
2011Rd 1 · #1Cam NewtonQBAuburn11568.2+46.810714893
2011Rd 3 · #65Terrell McClainDTSouth Florida1723.7−6.749220
2011Rd 3 · #97Sione FuaDTStanford518.1−13.144010
2011Rd 4 · #98Brandon HoganDBWest Virginia018.0−18.00300
2011Rd 5 · #132Kealoha PilaresWRHawaii113.7−12.712000
2011Rd 6 · #166Lawrence WilsonLBCentral Connecticut St.010.4−10.40000
2011Rd 6 · #203Zachary WilliamsOLWashington St.07.4−7.40000
2011Rd 7 · #244Lee ZiembaTAuburn14.6−3.61600
2010Rd 2 · #48Jimmy ClausenQBNotre Dame328.0−25.002110
2010Rd 3 · #78Brandon LaFellWRLSU4321.4+21.61912550
2010Rd 3 · #89Armanti EdwardsWRAppalachian St.119.5−18.514100
2010Rd 4 · #124Eric NorwoodLBSouth Carolina214.8−12.822800
2010Rd 6 · #175Greg HardyDEMississippi339.7+23.3277541
2010Rd 6 · #198David GettisWRBaylor37.8−4.831710
2010Rd 6 · #202Jordan PughDBTexas A&M47.5−3.534400
2010Rd 6 · #204Tony PikeQBCincinnati07.4−7.40100
2010Rd 7 · #223R.J. StanfordDBUtah46.0−2.014600
2010Rd 7 · #249Robert McClainDBConnecticut144.3+9.749410

How the grades work

Each player's value is Pro Football Reference's weighted career approximate value (AV), a single number for any position that counts a player's best seasons most. Each slot's expectation comes from one curve over the pick number, fitted to every draft since 2010 (an average pick = 1×: pick 1 3.8×, pick 10 2.6×, pick 32 1.9×, pick 64 1.3×, pick 100 1.0×, pick 200 0.4×), then scaled draft by draft to what that draft actually produced, so an older class isn't favored for having had more seasons. A class's score is its picks' value above or below their slots; the letter grades it against the same draft's 32 classes (A about the top sixth, F the bottom sixth).

Value counts the whole career wherever it was played; "Kept" is the share earned for the drafting team. Trades of picks are credited to the team that made the pick. Recent classes keep moving as careers go on.