NFL 2026 · Wk 11

Draft grades · 2010–2024

Cincinnati Bengals draft grades

Every Bengals pick since 2010: what each became against what picks in the same slot became in the same draft, class by class.

Share

Since 2010
#24 · D
−88.9 value above slot, rank of 32
Best class
2011 · A
+50.7, led by Andy Dalton
Pro Bowlers drafted
13
36 started 3+ seasons
Value kept
80%
of their picks' careers, earned for the Bengals

Class by class Drafts 2010–2026

Each class graded against the same draft's 32 classes once it has had two full seasons.

How to read

Value counts the players' whole careers, wherever they played.

DraftGradeRankPicksCareer valueValueSlots expectExp.Above slot+/-Pro BowlersBest value pick
2026–too early70––0–
2025–too early62216.2+5.80Dylan Fairchild Rd 3 · #81
2024D27th103444.3−10.30Amarius Mims Rd 1 · #18
2023B5th87052.2+17.80Chase Brown Rd 5 · #163
2022C14th66362.8+0.20Cordell Volson Rd 4 · #136
2021D22nd10101120.2−19.21Ja'Marr Chase Rd 1 · #5
2020B5th7171132.8+38.22Tee Higgins Rd 2 · #33
2019D26th10115144.8−29.80Germaine Pratt Rd 3 · #72
2018D24th11138175.7−37.71Jessie Bates III Rd 2 · #54
2017D30th11134181.0−47.02Joe Mixon Rd 2 · #48
2016C15th7140125.0+15.00Tyler Boyd Rd 2 · #55
2015F32nd960140.4−80.40C.J. Uzomah Rd 5 · #157
2014D25th883120.0−37.00Russell Bodine Rd 4 · #111
2013D23rd10132153.8−21.81Giovani Bernard Rd 2 · #37
2012B8th10240206.8+33.21Marvin Jones Rd 5 · #166
2011A5th8215164.3+50.72Andy Dalton Rd 2 · #35
2010B8th9198158.8+39.23Geno Atkins Rd 4 · #120

Every pick since 2010 Since 2010

Newest draft first. Every column sorts.

DraftPickPlayerPosCollegeValueSlot+/−KeptGamesStarter yrsPro Bowls
2026Rd 2 · #41Cashius HowellDETexas A&M0––0700
2026Rd 3 · #72Tacario DavisCBWashington0––0900
2026Rd 4 · #128Connor LewCAuburn0––0000
2026Rd 4 · #140Colbie YoungWRGeorgia0––0700
2026Rd 6 · #189Brian Parker IIOTDuke0––0000
2026Rd 7 · #221Jack EndriesTETexas0––0600
2026Rd 7 · #226Landon RobinsonNTNavy0––0000
2025Rd 1 · #17Shemar StewartDETexas A&M25.3−3.321400
2025Rd 2 · #49Demetrius KnightLBSouth Carolina63.6+2.462610
2025Rd 3 · #81Dylan FairchildOLGeorgia62.7+3.362410
2025Rd 4 · #119Barrett CarterLBClemson52.0+3.052610
2025Rd 5 · #153Jalen RiversOLMiami (FL)31.5+1.532500
2025Rd 6 · #193Tahj BrooksRBTexas Tech01.1−1.102500
2024Rd 1 · #18Amarius MimsOLGeorgia1611.1+4.9164120
2024Rd 2 · #49Kris JenkinsDLMichigan67.6−1.663800
2024Rd 3 · #80Jermaine BurtonWRAlabama15.8−4.811400
2024Rd 3 · #97McKinnley JacksonDLTexas A&M25.1−3.122200
2024Rd 4 · #115Erick AllTEIowa14.4−3.411510
2024Rd 5 · #149Josh NewtonCBTCU33.3−0.333700
2024Rd 6 · #194Tanner McLachlanTEArizona02.2−2.20200
2024Rd 6 · #214Cedric JohnsonDEMississippi21.8+0.222700
2024Rd 7 · #224Daijahn AnthonySAFMississippi11.6−0.611800
2024Rd 7 · #237Matt LeeCMiami (FL)21.4+0.622200
2023Rd 1 · #28Myles MurphyDEClemson715.0−8.075610
2023Rd 2 · #60DJ TurnerDBMichigan1210.8+1.2125430
2023Rd 3 · #95Jordan BattleDBAlabama128.0+4.0126010
2023Rd 4 · #131Charlie JonesWRPurdue46.0−2.043900
2023Rd 5 · #163Chase BrownRBIllinois224.6+17.4225410
2023Rd 6 · #206Andrei IosivasWRPrinceton93.1+5.995220
2023Rd 6 · #217Brad RobbinsPMichigan12.8−1.811810
2023Rd 7 · #246DJ IveyCBMiami (FL)31.9+1.134500
2022Rd 1 · #31Daxton HillDBMichigan1320.0−7.0136320
2022Rd 2 · #60Cam Taylor-BrittCBNebraska1514.9+0.1155330
2022Rd 3 · #95Zachary CarterDEFlorida1011.1−1.194910
2022Rd 4 · #136Cordell VolsonTNorth Dakota St.228.0+14.0225030
2022Rd 5 · #166Tycen AndersonSToledo26.3−4.325000
2022Rd 7 · #252Jeff GunterOLBCoastal Carolina12.5−1.511000
2021Rd 1 · #5Ja'Marr ChaseWRLSU5835.6+22.4588755
2021Rd 2 · #46Jackson CarmanTClemson518.7−13.743000
2021Rd 3 · #69Joseph OssaiLBTexas1015.1−5.1106510
2021Rd 4 · #111Cameron SampleDETulane710.7−3.776100
2021Rd 4 · #122Tyler ShelvinDTLSU09.8−9.80500
2021Rd 4 · #139D'Ante SmithTEast Carolina18.6−7.61300
2021Rd 5 · #149Evan McPhersonKFlorida157.9+7.1158730
2021Rd 6 · #190Trey HillOLGeorgia35.5−2.532500
2021Rd 6 · #202Chris EvansRBMichigan24.9−2.923400
2021Rd 7 · #235Wyatt HubertDEKansas St.03.4−3.40000
2020Rd 1 · #1Joe BurrowQBLSU6353.6+9.4638653
2020Rd 2 · #33Tee HigginsWRClemson4325.5+17.5439451
2020Rd 3 · #65Logan WilsonLBWyoming3218.6+13.4318340
2020Rd 4 · #107Akeem Davis-GaitherLBAppalachian St.1413.2+0.899610
2020Rd 5 · #147Khalid KareemDENotre Dame29.6−7.624200
2020Rd 6 · #180Hakeem AdenijiTKansas107.2+2.895500
2020Rd 7 · #215Markus BaileyLBPurdue75.1+1.976100
2019Rd 1 · #11Jonah WilliamsGAlabama3739.2−2.2317450
2019Rd 2 · #52Drew SampleTEWashington722.9−15.9710440
2019Rd 3 · #72Germaine PrattLBNorth Carolina St.4519.2+25.83711370
2019Rd 4 · #104Ryan FinleyQBNorth Carolina St.214.8−12.82800
2019Rd 4 · #125Renell WrenDTArizona St.212.5−10.521300
2019Rd 4 · #136Michael JordanGOhio St.1811.5+6.587840
2019Rd 6 · #182Trayveon WilliamsRBTexas A&M47.8−3.837500
2019Rd 6 · #210Deshaun DavisLBAuburn05.9−5.90000
2019Rd 6 · #211Rodney AndersonRBOklahoma05.9−5.90000
2019Rd 7 · #223Jordan BrownCBSouth Dakota St.05.1−5.10000
2018Rd 1 · #21Billy PriceCOhio St.1839.8−21.896930
2018Rd 2 · #54Jessie Bates IIISWake Forest5527.3+27.72813981
2018Rd 3 · #77Sam HubbardDEOhio St.4022.3+17.74010460
2018Rd 3 · #78Malik JeffersonOLBTexas322.1−19.113800
2018Rd 4 · #112Mark WaltonRBMiami (FL)316.8−13.812100
2018Rd 5 · #151Davontae HarrisCBIllinois St.512.3−7.304200
2018Rd 5 · #158Andrew BrownDEVirginia211.6−9.622800
2018Rd 5 · #170Darius PhillipsCBWestern Michigan710.5−3.575610
2018Rd 7 · #249Logan WoodsideQBToledo04.5−4.501300
2018Rd 7 · #252Rod TaylorGMississippi04.3−4.30000
2018Rd 7 · #253Auden TateWRFlorida St.54.2+0.853510
2017Rd 1 · #9John RossWRWashington747.7−40.753810
2017Rd 2 · #48Joe MixonRBOklahoma5627.7+28.34911162
2017Rd 3 · #73Jordan WillisOLBKansas St.822.1−14.146900
2017Rd 4 · #116Carl LawsonOLBAuburn2015.6+4.4109120
2017Rd 4 · #128Josh MaloneWRTennessee114.2−13.212610
2017Rd 4 · #138Ryan GlasgowDTMichigan313.1−10.132600
2017Rd 5 · #153Jake ElliottKMemphis2411.6+12.4015631
2017Rd 5 · #176JJ DielmanCUtah09.5−9.50000
2017Rd 6 · #193Jordan EvansLBOklahoma98.2+0.896500
2017Rd 6 · #207Brandon WilsonRBHouston67.1−1.166000
2017Rd 7 · #251Mason SchreckTEBuffalo04.2−4.202600
2016Rd 1 · #24William Jackson IIICBHouston1938.0−19.0157540
2016Rd 2 · #55Tyler BoydWRPittsburgh4827.0+21.04613650
2016Rd 3 · #87Nick VigilILBUtah St.2720.5+6.51711340
2016Rd 4 · #122Andrew BillingsNTBaylor3315.5+17.51411460
2016Rd 5 · #161Christian WestermanGArizona St.211.3−9.321600
2016Rd 6 · #199Cody CoreWRMississippi38.0−5.035100
2016Rd 7 · #245Clayton FejedelemSIllinois84.7+3.3610700
2015Rd 1 · #21Cedric OgbuehiTTexas A&M1734.5−17.5116720
2015Rd 2 · #53Jake FisherTOregon923.9−14.994800
2015Rd 3 · #85Tyler KroftTERutgers918.1−9.1610020
2015Rd 3 · #99Paul DawsonILBTCU116.2−15.211600
2015Rd 4 · #120Josh ShawCBUSC713.7−6.775500
2015Rd 4 · #135Marcus HardisonDEArizona St.012.2−12.20000
2015Rd 5 · #157C.J. UzomahTEAuburn1410.2+3.81311340
2015Rd 6 · #197Derron SmithSFresno St.37.1−4.123800
2015Rd 7 · #238Mario AlfordWRWest Virginia04.5−4.50400
2014Rd 1 · #24Darqueze DennardDBMichigan St.1335.1−22.1128700
2014Rd 2 · #55Jeremy HillRBLSU2125.0−4.0215530
2014Rd 3 · #88Will ClarkeDEWest Virginia618.8−12.845300
2014Rd 4 · #111Russell BodineCNorth Carolina3015.7+14.3287450
2014Rd 5 · #164A.J. McCarronQBAlabama410.2−6.231900
2014Rd 6 · #212Marquis FlowersLBArizona76.5+0.545300
2014Rd 7 · #239James WrightWRLSU24.7−2.722400
2014Rd 7 · #252Lavelle WestbrooksDBGeorgia Southern04.0−4.00000
2013Rd 1 · #21Tyler EifertTENotre Dame1934.9−15.9177421
2013Rd 2 · #37Giovani BernardRBNorth Carolina4228.5+13.54113520
2013Rd 2 · #53Margus HuntDESMU1824.2−6.2411410
2013Rd 3 · #84Shawn WilliamsDBGeorgia2518.5+6.52412540
2013Rd 4 · #118Sean PorterLBTexas A&M014.1−14.10300
2013Rd 5 · #156Tanner HawkinsonTKansas010.4−10.40400
2013Rd 6 · #190Rex BurkheadRBNebraska217.7+13.3411500
2013Rd 6 · #197Cobi HamiltonWRArkansas27.2−5.201410
2013Rd 7 · #240Reid FragelOLOhio St.04.5−4.50100
2013Rd 7 · #251T.J. JohnsonCSouth Carolina53.8+1.254500
2012Rd 1 · #17Dre KirkpatrickDBAlabama3142.6−11.62511950
2012Rd 1 · #27Kevin ZeitlerGWisconsin6736.8+30.229218141
2012Rd 2 · #53Devon StillDTPenn St.327.7−24.733300
2012Rd 3 · #83Mohamed SanuWRRutgers4121.3+19.71513650
2012Rd 3 · #93Brandon ThompsonDTClemson719.7−12.773900
2012Rd 4 · #116Orson CharlesTEGeorgia216.4−14.414900
2012Rd 5 · #156Shaun PraterDBIowa211.9−9.902100
2012Rd 5 · #166Marvin JonesWRCalifornia5310.9+42.11515180
2012Rd 5 · #167George IlokaDBBoise St.2910.8+18.22710340
2012Rd 6 · #191Dan HerronRBOhio St.58.7−3.703500
2011Rd 1 · #4A.J. GreenWRGeorgia7756.0+21.071158107
2011Rd 2 · #35Andy DaltonQBTCU9231.8+60.282180113
2011Rd 3 · #66Dontay MochLBNevada023.5−23.50800
2011Rd 4 · #101Clint BolingGGeorgia4617.6+28.44611170
2011Rd 5 · #134Robert SandsDBWest Virginia013.5−13.50100
2011Rd 6 · #167Ryan WhalenWRStanford010.3−10.301700
2011Rd 7 · #207Korey LindseyDBSouthern Illinois07.1−7.10000
2011Rd 7 · #246Jay FinleyRBBaylor04.5−4.50000
2010Rd 1 · #21Jermaine GreshamTEOklahoma2838.4−10.42213292
2010Rd 2 · #54Carlos DunlapDEFlorida6726.4+40.66219772
2010Rd 3 · #84Jordan ShipleyWRTexas720.3−13.352400
2010Rd 3 · #96Brandon GheeDBWake Forest218.5−16.512900
2010Rd 4 · #120Geno AtkinsDTGeorgia8915.3+73.78916198
2010Rd 4 · #131Roddrick MuckelroyLBTexas114.0−13.011900
2010Rd 5 · #152Otis HudsonTEastern Illinois011.8−11.80000
2010Rd 6 · #191Dezmon BriscoeWRKansas48.4−4.402500
2010Rd 7 · #228Reggie StephensCIowa St.05.7−5.70000

How the grades work

Each player's value is Pro Football Reference's weighted career approximate value (AV), a single number for any position that counts a player's best seasons most. Each slot's expectation comes from one curve over the pick number, fitted to every draft since 2010 (an average pick = 1×: pick 1 3.8×, pick 10 2.6×, pick 32 1.9×, pick 64 1.3×, pick 100 1.0×, pick 200 0.4×), then scaled draft by draft to what that draft actually produced, so an older class isn't favored for having had more seasons. A class's score is its picks' value above or below their slots; the letter grades it against the same draft's 32 classes (A about the top sixth, F the bottom sixth).

Value counts the whole career wherever it was played; "Kept" is the share earned for the drafting team. Trades of picks are credited to the team that made the pick. Recent classes keep moving as careers go on.