NFL 2026 · Wk 11

Draft grades · 2010–2024

Indianapolis Colts draft grades

Every Colts pick since 2010: what each became against what picks in the same slot became in the same draft, class by class.

Share

Since 2010
#21 · C
−57.3 value above slot, rank of 32
Best class
2018 · A
+56.8, led by Zaire Franklin
Pro Bowlers drafted
7
31 started 3+ seasons
Value kept
81%
of their picks' careers, earned for the Colts

Class by class Drafts 2010–2026

Each class graded against the same draft's 32 classes once it has had two full seasons.

How to read

Value counts the players' whole careers, wherever they played.

DraftGradeRankPicksCareer valueValueSlots expectExp.Above slot+/-Pro BowlersBest value pick
2026–too early80––0–
2025–too early81618.3−2.31Tyler Warren Rd 1 · #14
2024B6th95342.5+10.50Jonah Laulu Rd 7 · #234
2023F32nd125787.7−30.70Josh Downs Rd 3 · #79
2022B9th88571.6+13.40Bernhard Raimann Rd 3 · #77
2021C13th77469.7+4.30Will Fries Rd 7 · #248
2020A4th9149107.6+41.41Jonathan Taylor Rd 2 · #41
2019F29th10103137.9−34.90Bobby Okereke Rd 3 · #89
2018A4th11290233.2+56.83Zaire Franklin Rd 7 · #235
2017C13th8152151.3+0.70Grover Stewart Rd 4 · #144
2016C16th8156142.3+13.71Austin Blythe Rd 7 · #248
2015D20th884111.5−27.50Denzelle Good Rd 7 · #255
2014C21st54764.9−17.90–
2013F25th73893.6−55.60Kerwynn Williams Rd 7 · #230
2012C16th10196201.0−5.02T.Y. Hilton Rd 3 · #92
2011D25th573108.3−35.30Anthony Castonzo Rd 1 · #22
2010C14th8125116.2+8.80Jerry Hughes Rd 1 · #31

Every pick since 2010 Since 2010

Newest draft first. Every column sorts.

DraftPickPlayerPosCollegeValueSlot+/−KeptGamesStarter yrsPro Bowls
2026Rd 2 · #53CJ AllenLBGeorgia0––0700
2026Rd 3 · #78A.J. HaulcySLSU0––0900
2026Rd 4 · #113Jalen FarmerGKentucky0––01000
2026Rd 4 · #135Bryce BoettcherLBOregon0––0800
2026Rd 5 · #156George GumbsDEFlorida0––0600
2026Rd 6 · #214Caden CurryDEOhio St.0––01000
2026Rd 7 · #237Seth McGowanRBKentucky0––01000
2026Rd 7 · #254Deion BurksWROklahoma0––01000
2025Rd 1 · #14Tyler WarrenTEPenn St.95.6+3.492511
2025Rd 2 · #45JT TuimoloauDEOhio St.13.7−2.712300
2025Rd 3 · #80Justin WalleyCBMinnesota02.7−2.70800
2025Rd 4 · #127Jalen TravisOTIowa St.31.9+1.132600
2025Rd 5 · #151DJ GiddensRBKansas St.11.5−0.511100
2025Rd 6 · #189Riley LeonardQBNotre Dame21.1+0.92500
2025Rd 6 · #190Tim SmithDLAlabama01.1−1.101000
2025Rd 7 · #232Hunter WohlerSAFWisconsin00.7−0.701000
2024Rd 1 · #15Laiatu LatuDLUCLA1011.7−1.7104310
2024Rd 2 · #52Adonai MitchellWRTexas87.4+0.653910
2024Rd 3 · #79Matt GoncalvesOLPittsburgh125.8+6.2124310
2024Rd 4 · #117Tanor BortoliniOLWisconsin104.3+5.7103810
2024Rd 5 · #142Anthony GouldWROregon St.03.5−3.502600
2024Rd 5 · #151Jaylon CarliesDBMissouri33.3−0.332000
2024Rd 5 · #164Jaylin SimpsonSAFAuburn02.9−2.90800
2024Rd 6 · #201Micah AbrahamCBMarshall02.1−2.10000
2024Rd 7 · #234Jonah LauluDLOklahoma101.5+8.504110
2023Rd 1 · #4Anthony RichardsonQBFlorida924.4−15.491810
2023Rd 2 · #44Julius BrentsDBKansas St.412.5−8.532700
2023Rd 3 · #79Josh DownsWRNorth Carolina199.1+9.9195720
2023Rd 4 · #106Blake FreelandOLBYU67.4−1.462510
2023Rd 4 · #110Adetomiwa AdebaworeDLNorthwestern67.1−1.165300
2023Rd 5 · #138Darius RushDBSouth Carolina05.7−5.70600
2023Rd 5 · #158Daniel ScottSCalifornia04.8−4.80400
2023Rd 5 · #162Will MalloryTEMiami (FL)24.7−2.722700
2023Rd 5 · #176Evan HullRBNorthwestern04.1−4.101200
2023Rd 6 · #211Titus LeoLBWagner03.0−3.00400
2023Rd 7 · #221Jaylon JonesDBTexas A&M112.7+8.3114620
2023Rd 7 · #236Jake WittOLNorthern Michigan02.2−2.20000
2022Rd 2 · #53Alec PierceWRCincinnati2615.9+10.1266640
2022Rd 3 · #73Jelani WoodsTEVirginia213.3−11.322800
2022Rd 3 · #77Bernhard RaimannOLCentral Michigan2512.9+12.1257140
2022Rd 3 · #96Nick CrossDBMaryland1511.0+4.0157320
2022Rd 5 · #159Eric JohnsonDTMissouri State46.6−2.635100
2022Rd 6 · #192Andrew OgletreeTEYoungstown St.25.0−3.025410
2022Rd 6 · #216Curtis BrooksDTCincinnati03.9−3.90000
2022Rd 7 · #239Rodney Thomas IILBYale113.0+8.0117820
2021Rd 1 · #21Kwity PayeDLMichigan3225.2+6.8328550
2021Rd 2 · #54Dayo OdeyingboDLVanderbilt1517.3−2.3127410
2021Rd 4 · #127Kylen GransonTESMU89.5−1.588200
2021Rd 5 · #165Shawn DavisDBFlorida06.9−6.90100
2021Rd 6 · #218Sam EhlingerQBTexas24.2−2.22800
2021Rd 7 · #229Mike StrachanWRCharleston (WV)03.7−3.702300
2021Rd 7 · #248Will FriesOLPenn St.172.9+14.1116730
2020Rd 2 · #34Michael Pittman Jr.WRUSC4425.2+18.8449860
2020Rd 2 · #41Jonathan TaylorRBWisconsin5823.4+34.6589453
2020Rd 3 · #85Julian BlackmonSUtah2015.7+4.3207640
2020Rd 4 · #122Jacob EasonQBWashington011.7−11.70200
2020Rd 5 · #149Danny PinterGBall St.79.4−2.477700
2020Rd 6 · #193Robert WindsorDTPenn St.06.4−6.40200
2020Rd 6 · #211Isaiah RodgersCBMassachusetts185.3+12.778620
2020Rd 6 · #212Dezmon PatmonWRWashington St.05.3−5.301000
2020Rd 6 · #213Jordan GlasgowLBMichigan25.2−3.222500
2019Rd 2 · #34Rock Ya-SinCBTemple1727.6−10.61110410
2019Rd 2 · #49Ben BanoguLBTCU423.6−19.645000
2019Rd 2 · #59Parris CampbellWROhio St.921.5−12.595010
2019Rd 3 · #89Bobby OkerekeLBStanford3916.6+22.42111770
2019Rd 4 · #109Khari WillisSMichigan St.1214.2−2.2123910
2019Rd 5 · #144Marvell Tell IIISUSC110.7−9.711300
2019Rd 5 · #164E.J. SpeedLBTarleton St.209.1+10.91610830
2019Rd 6 · #199Gerri GreenDEMississippi St.06.6−6.60100
2019Rd 7 · #240Jackson BartonTUtah14.2−3.201300
2019Rd 7 · #246Javon PattersonCMississippi03.8−3.80100
2018Rd 1 · #6Quenton NelsonGNotre Dame7954.3+24.77913788
2018Rd 2 · #36Shaquille LeonardLBSouth Carolina St.6032.8+27.2597553
2018Rd 2 · #37Braden SmithGAuburn4532.4+12.64510880
2018Rd 2 · #52Kemoko TurayOLBRutgers527.8−22.854100
2018Rd 2 · #64Tyquan LewisDEOhio St.1324.9−11.9138800
2018Rd 4 · #104Nyheim HinesRBNorth Carolina St.2517.9+7.1228500
2018Rd 5 · #159Daurice FountainWRNorthern Iowa011.5−11.50800
2018Rd 5 · #169Jordan WilkinsRBMississippi810.6−2.685400
2018Rd 6 · #185Deon CainWRClemson19.2−8.201500
2018Rd 7 · #221Matthew AdamsLBHouston146.4+7.699810
2018Rd 7 · #235Zaire FranklinLBSyracuse405.4+34.64013851
2017Rd 1 · #15Malik HookerSOhio St.2642.0−16.01312060
2017Rd 2 · #46Quincy WilsonCBFlorida428.3−24.343300
2017Rd 3 · #80Tarell BashamDEOhio1320.8−7.818210
2017Rd 4 · #137Zach BannerTUSC213.2−11.203000
2017Rd 4 · #143Marlon MackRBSouth Florida2012.6+7.4195520
2017Rd 4 · #144Grover StewartDTAlbany State (GA)4212.5+29.54215170
2017Rd 5 · #158Nate HairstonCBTemple911.1−2.156110
2017Rd 5 · #161Anthony WalkerLBNorthwestern3610.8+25.22210150
2016Rd 1 · #18Ryan KellyCAlabama5641.6+14.45412994
2016Rd 2 · #57T.J. GreenSClemson626.5−20.554100
2016Rd 3 · #82Le'Raven ClarkTTexas Tech1221.3−9.3106400
2016Rd 4 · #116Hassan RidgewayDTTexas1316.3−3.358000
2016Rd 4 · #125Antonio MorrisonILBFlorida1315.1−2.194720
2016Rd 5 · #155Joe HaegTNorth Dakota St.2211.9+10.1198020
2016Rd 7 · #239Trevor BatesLBMaine15.1−4.101000
2016Rd 7 · #248Austin BlytheCIowa334.5+28.519240
2015Rd 1 · #29Phillip DorsettWRMiami (FL)1630.9−14.979400
2015Rd 3 · #65D'Joun SmithCBFlorida Atlantic021.4−21.40500
2015Rd 3 · #93Henry AndersonDEStanford2117.0+4.088940
2015Rd 4 · #109Clayton GeathersSCentral Florida1314.9−1.9135630
2015Rd 5 · #151David ParryNTStanford1310.7+2.3133620
2015Rd 6 · #205Josh RobinsonRBMississippi St.06.6−6.60500
2015Rd 6 · #207Amarlo HerreraILBGeorgia06.4−6.40300
2015Rd 7 · #255Denzelle GoodTMars Hill213.6+17.4106220
2014Rd 2 · #59Jack MewhortTOhio St.2224.1−2.1224540
2014Rd 3 · #90Donte MoncriefWRMississippi1818.5−0.5158330
2014Rd 5 · #166Jonathan NewsomeLBBall St.410.0−6.043000
2014Rd 6 · #203Andrew JacksonLBWestern Kentucky17.1−6.111300
2014Rd 7 · #232Ulrick JohnOLGeorgia St.25.2−3.201000
2013Rd 1 · #24Bjoern WernerDEFlorida St.1033.4−23.4103810
2013Rd 3 · #86Hugh ThorntonGIllinois1618.2−2.2163730
2013Rd 4 · #121Khaled HolmesCUSC413.8−9.841700
2013Rd 5 · #139Montori HughesDTUT Martin211.9−9.922500
2013Rd 6 · #192John BoyettDBOregon07.6−7.60000
2013Rd 7 · #230Kerwynn WilliamsRBUtah St.65.0+1.004000
2013Rd 7 · #254Justice CunninghamTESouth Carolina03.7−3.70300
2012Rd 1 · #1Andrew LuckQBStanford7271.7+0.3728654
2012Rd 2 · #34Coby FleenerTEStanford2533.8−8.8188740
2012Rd 3 · #64Dwayne AllenTEClemson1225.1−13.1118640
2012Rd 3 · #92T.Y. HiltonWRFlorida International7219.8+52.27114684
2012Rd 5 · #136Josh ChapmanNTAlabama714.0−7.072910
2012Rd 5 · #170Vick BallardRBMississippi St.510.6−5.651710
2012Rd 6 · #206LaVon BrazillWROhio37.5−4.532500
2012Rd 7 · #208Justin AndersonOLGeorgia07.4−7.40000
2012Rd 7 · #214Tim FuggerDEVanderbilt06.9−6.90000
2012Rd 7 · #253Chandler HarnishQBNorthern Illinois04.2−4.20000
2011Rd 1 · #22Anthony CastonzoTBoston Col.5837.5+20.558144100
2011Rd 2 · #49Ben IjalanaTVillanova627.4−21.403410
2011Rd 3 · #87Drake NevisDTLSU419.7−15.732600
2011Rd 4 · #119Delone CarterRBSyracuse315.2−12.232700
2011Rd 6 · #188Chris RuckerDBMichigan St.28.5−6.521500
2010Rd 1 · #31Jerry HughesDETCU6833.6+34.4322590
2010Rd 2 · #63Pat AngererLBIowa1824.3−6.3185430
2010Rd 3 · #94Kevin ThomasDBUSC218.8−16.82900
2010Rd 4 · #129Jacques McClendonGTennessee314.2−11.202500
2010Rd 5 · #162Brody EldridgeTEOklahoma010.9−10.902720
2010Rd 7 · #238Ricardo MathewsDTCincinnati145.0+9.059600
2010Rd 7 · #240Kavell ConnerLBClemson204.9+15.1157830
2010Rd 7 · #246Ray FisherDBIndiana04.5−4.50000

How the grades work

Each player's value is Pro Football Reference's weighted career approximate value (AV), a single number for any position that counts a player's best seasons most. Each slot's expectation comes from one curve over the pick number, fitted to every draft since 2010 (an average pick = 1×: pick 1 3.8×, pick 10 2.6×, pick 32 1.9×, pick 64 1.3×, pick 100 1.0×, pick 200 0.4×), then scaled draft by draft to what that draft actually produced, so an older class isn't favored for having had more seasons. A class's score is its picks' value above or below their slots; the letter grades it against the same draft's 32 classes (A about the top sixth, F the bottom sixth).

Value counts the whole career wherever it was played; "Kept" is the share earned for the drafting team. Trades of picks are credited to the team that made the pick. Recent classes keep moving as careers go on.