NFL 2026 · Wk 11

Draft grades · 2010–2024

New York Giants draft grades

Every Giants pick since 2010: what each became against what picks in the same slot became in the same draft, class by class.

Share

Since 2010
#29 · F
−285.1 value above slot, rank of 32
Best class
2024 · A
+17.3, led by Tyrone Tracy Jr.
Pro Bowlers drafted
10
29 started 3+ seasons
Value kept
67%
of their picks' careers, earned for the Giants

Class by class Drafts 2010–2026

Each class graded against the same draft's 32 classes once it has had two full seasons.

How to read

Value counts the players' whole careers, wherever they played.

DraftGradeRankPicksCareer valueValueSlots expectExp.Above slot+/-Pro BowlersBest value pick
2026–too early70––0–
2025–too early72520.5+4.50Jaxson Dart Rd 1 · #25
2024A3rd65638.7+17.31Tyrone Tracy Jr. Rd 5 · #166
2023D24th73747.6−10.60John Michael Schmitz Rd 2 · #57
2022F31st11116151.8−35.80Micah McFadden Rd 5 · #146
2021F30th62979.0−50.00–
2020C20th10117127.4−10.41Xavier McKinney Rd 2 · #36
2019B11th10189174.6+14.42Darius Slayton Rd 5 · #171
2018C14th6171178.2−7.21B.J. Hill Rd 3 · #69
2017C17th6104113.4−9.41Dalvin Tomlinson Rd 2 · #55
2016D23rd699142.1−43.10B.J. Goodson Rd 4 · #109
2015C19th6108116.9−8.91Bobby Hart Rd 7 · #226
2014C15th7140136.4+3.61Devon Kennard Rd 5 · #174
2013C18th7102115.0−13.00Johnathan Hankins Rd 2 · #49
2012F32nd745122.1−77.10Markus Kuhn Rd 7 · #239
2011F31st862131.9−69.90Jacquian Williams Rd 6 · #202
2010C12th7151136.0+15.02Linval Joseph Rd 2 · #46

Every pick since 2010 Since 2010

Newest draft first. Every column sorts.

DraftPickPlayerPosCollegeValueSlot+/−KeptGamesStarter yrsPro Bowls
2026Rd 1 · #5Arvell ReeseLBOhio St.0––0900
2026Rd 1 · #10Francis MauigoaOTMiami (FL)0––0900
2026Rd 2 · #37Colton HoodCBTennessee0––0700
2026Rd 3 · #74Malachi FieldsWRNotre Dame0––0900
2026Rd 6 · #186Bobby Jamison-TravisDLAuburn0––0400
2026Rd 6 · #192J.C. DavisOTIllinois0––0300
2026Rd 6 · #193Jack KellyLBBYU0––0900
2025Rd 1 · #3Abdul CarterDEPenn St.47.6−3.642600
2025Rd 1 · #25Jaxson DartQBMississippi114.7+6.3111610
2025Rd 3 · #65Darius AlexanderDTToledo23.1−1.122400
2025Rd 4 · #105Cam SkatteboRBArizona St.52.2+2.851600
2025Rd 5 · #154Marcus MbowOLPurdue21.5+0.522000
2025Rd 7 · #219Thomas FidoneTENebraska00.8−0.801000
2025Rd 7 · #246Korie BlackCBOklahoma St.10.6+0.411100
2024Rd 1 · #6Malik NabersWRLSU1214.5−2.5122811
2024Rd 2 · #47Tyler NubinDBMinnesota97.8+1.293320
2024Rd 3 · #70Andru PhillipsDBKentucky66.3−0.364000
2024Rd 4 · #107Theo JohnsonTEPenn St.74.7+2.373420
2024Rd 5 · #166Tyrone Tracy Jr.RBPurdue142.9+11.1143920
2024Rd 6 · #183Darius MuasauLBUCLA82.5+5.583710
2023Rd 1 · #24Deonte BanksDBMaryland1215.9−3.9125220
2023Rd 2 · #57John Michael SchmitzOLMinnesota1411.1+2.9144630
2023Rd 3 · #73Jalin HyattWRTennessee39.6−6.634400
2023Rd 5 · #172Eric GrayRBOklahoma14.3−3.313400
2023Rd 6 · #209Tre HawkinsCBOld Dominion33.0+0.032100
2023Rd 7 · #243Jordon RileyDLOregon42.0+2.042900
2023Rd 7 · #254Gervarrius OwensDBHouston01.7−1.70500
2022Rd 1 · #5Kayvon ThibodeauxDEOregon2432.4−8.4246230
2022Rd 1 · #7Evan NealOLAlabama1130.3−19.3112910
2022Rd 2 · #43Wan'Dale RobinsonWRKentucky2017.5+2.5206310
2022Rd 3 · #67Joshua EzeuduOLNorth Carolina514.0−9.054100
2022Rd 3 · #81Cordale FlottCBLSU1212.4−0.4126120
2022Rd 4 · #112Daniel BellingerTESan Diego St.99.7−0.797130
2022Rd 4 · #114Dane BeltonDBIowa109.5+0.5107610
2022Rd 5 · #146Micah McFaddenLBIndiana187.4+10.6185620
2022Rd 5 · #147DJ DavidsonDTArizona St.57.3−2.354700
2022Rd 5 · #173Marcus McKethanOLNorth Carolina25.9−3.921600
2022Rd 6 · #182Darrian BeaversLBCincinnati05.4−5.40200
2021Rd 1 · #20Kadarius ToneyWRFlorida725.6−18.633500
2021Rd 2 · #50Azeez OjulariOLBGeorgia1718.0−1.0164910
2021Rd 3 · #71Aaron RobinsonDBCentral Florida214.9−12.921100
2021Rd 4 · #116Elerson SmithDLNorthern Iowa110.3−9.311500
2021Rd 6 · #196Gary BrightwellRBArizona15.2−4.214100
2021Rd 6 · #201Rodarius WilliamsCBOklahoma St.15.0−4.01800
2020Rd 1 · #4Andrew ThomasTGeorgia3344.0−11.0338360
2020Rd 2 · #36Xavier McKinneySAlabama3924.7+14.3159251
2020Rd 3 · #99Matt PeartTConnecticut714.0−7.057500
2020Rd 4 · #110Darnay HolmesCBUCLA812.9−4.978300
2020Rd 5 · #150Shane LemieuxGOregon59.3−4.332510
2020Rd 6 · #183Cam BrownLBPenn St.47.0−3.046000
2020Rd 7 · #218Carter CoughlinLBMinnesota55.0+0.055600
2020Rd 7 · #238T.J. BrunsonLBSouth Carolina03.9−3.90500
2020Rd 7 · #247Chris WilliamsonCBMinnesota03.5−3.50500
2020Rd 7 · #255Tae CrowderLBGeorgia163.1+12.9164320
2019Rd 1 · #6Daniel JonesQBDuke5244.7+7.3409360
2019Rd 1 · #17Dexter LawrenceDTClemson5534.9+20.15511863
2019Rd 1 · #30Deandre BakerCBGeorgia629.0−23.052610
2019Rd 3 · #95Oshane XiminesDEOld Dominion815.9−7.985000
2019Rd 4 · #108Julian LoveCBNotre Dame2714.3+12.71211531
2019Rd 5 · #143Ryan ConnellyLBWisconsin410.8−6.823200
2019Rd 5 · #171Darius SlaytonWRAuburn328.6+23.43210660
2019Rd 6 · #180Corey BallentineCBWashburn57.9−2.927500
2019Rd 7 · #232George Asafo-AdjeiTKentucky04.6−4.60000
2019Rd 7 · #245Chris SlaytonDTSyracuse03.9−3.90000
2018Rd 1 · #2Saquon BarkleyRBPenn St.6565.2−0.24011373
2018Rd 2 · #34Will HernandezGTexas-El Paso3833.6+4.42210450
2018Rd 3 · #66Lorenzo CarterDEGeorgia3024.5+5.5169640
2018Rd 3 · #69B.J. HillDTNorth Carolina St.3723.9+13.1713560
2018Rd 4 · #108Kyle LaulettaQBRichmond017.4−17.40200
2018Rd 5 · #139R.J. McIntoshDTMiami (FL)113.6−12.611800
2017Rd 1 · #23Evan EngramTEMississippi3737.0+0.01813382
2017Rd 2 · #55Dalvin TomlinsonDTAlabama5025.9+24.12314990
2017Rd 3 · #87Davis WebbQBCalifornia119.7−18.71200
2017Rd 4 · #140Wayne GallmanRBClemson1212.9−0.9116110
2017Rd 5 · #167Avery MossDEYoungstown St.410.3−6.322210
2017Rd 6 · #200Adam BisnowatyTPittsburgh07.6−7.60100
2016Rd 1 · #10Eli AppleCBOhio St.2848.5−20.5910450
2016Rd 2 · #40Sterling ShepardWROklahoma3231.3+0.72611950
2016Rd 3 · #71Darian ThompsonSBoise St.1223.4−11.466310
2016Rd 4 · #109B.J. GoodsonOLBClemson2017.2+2.896740
2016Rd 5 · #149Paul PerkinsRBUCLA512.5−7.552900
2016Rd 6 · #184Jerell AdamsTESouth Carolina29.2−7.223000
2015Rd 1 · #9Ereck FlowersTMiami (FL)3543.2−8.21810570
2015Rd 2 · #33Landon CollinsSAlabama4229.5+12.53210063
2015Rd 3 · #74Owamagbe OdighizuwaDEUCLA119.8−18.811800
2015Rd 5 · #144Mykkele ThompsonSTexas011.3−11.30100
2015Rd 6 · #186Geremy DavisWRConnecticut07.9−7.903600
2015Rd 7 · #226Bobby HartGFlorida St.305.2+24.8711040
2014Rd 1 · #12Odell Beckham Jr.WRLSU5942.9+16.14112363
2014Rd 2 · #43Weston RichburgOLColorado St.3328.1+4.9217950
2014Rd 3 · #74Jay BromleyDTSyracuse521.1−16.155700
2014Rd 4 · #113Andre WilliamsRBBoston Col.715.4−8.464100
2014Rd 5 · #152Nat BerheDBSan Diego St.311.3−8.334200
2014Rd 5 · #174Devon KennardDEUSC339.3+23.71311850
2014Rd 6 · #187Bennett JacksonDBNotre Dame08.3−8.301000
2013Rd 1 · #19Justin PughTSyracuse4636.0+10.025132100
2013Rd 2 · #49Johnathan HankinsDTOhio St.5025.2+24.817169100
2013Rd 3 · #81Damontre MooreDETexas A&M519.0−14.046600
2013Rd 4 · #110Ryan NassibQBSyracuse015.0−15.00500
2013Rd 5 · #152Cooper TaylorDBRichmond110.7−9.711600
2013Rd 7 · #225Eric HermanOLOhio05.4−5.40000
2013Rd 7 · #253Michael CoxRBMassachusetts03.7−3.701800
2012Rd 1 · #32David WilsonRBVirginia Tech534.6−29.652100
2012Rd 2 · #63Rueben RandleWRLSU2125.3−4.3216420
2012Rd 3 · #94Jayron HosleyDBVirginia Tech819.5−11.584300
2012Rd 4 · #127Adrien RobinsonTECincinnati015.0−15.001900
2012Rd 4 · #131Brandon MosleyTAuburn214.6−12.622200
2012Rd 6 · #201Matt McCantsTAla-Birmingham37.9−4.903000
2012Rd 7 · #239Markus KuhnDTNorth Carolina St.65.2+0.863900
2011Rd 1 · #19Prince AmukamaraDBNebraska3639.3−3.31511380
2011Rd 2 · #52Marvin AustinDTNorth Carolina226.6−24.612600
2011Rd 3 · #83Jerrel JerniganWRTroy220.3−18.323400
2011Rd 4 · #117James BrewerTIndiana415.5−11.542600
2011Rd 6 · #185Greg JonesLBMichigan St.38.8−5.832200
2011Rd 6 · #198Tyler SashDBIowa17.8−6.812300
2011Rd 6 · #202Jacquian WilliamsLBSouth Florida137.5+5.5135110
2011Rd 7 · #221Da'Rel ScottRBMaryland16.1−5.112000
2010Rd 1 · #15Jason Pierre-PaulDESouth Florida7442.4+31.646185113
2010Rd 2 · #46Linval JosephDTEast Carolina7028.5+41.516203112
2010Rd 3 · #76Chad JonesDBLSU021.7−21.70000
2010Rd 4 · #115Phillip DillardLBNebraska015.9−15.90700
2010Rd 5 · #147Mitch PetrusGArkansas412.3−8.342700
2010Rd 6 · #184Adrian TracyDEWilliam & Mary19.0−8.011600
2010Rd 7 · #221Matt DodgePEast Carolina26.2−4.221600

How the grades work

Each player's value is Pro Football Reference's weighted career approximate value (AV), a single number for any position that counts a player's best seasons most. Each slot's expectation comes from one curve over the pick number, fitted to every draft since 2010 (an average pick = 1×: pick 1 3.8×, pick 10 2.6×, pick 32 1.9×, pick 64 1.3×, pick 100 1.0×, pick 200 0.4×), then scaled draft by draft to what that draft actually produced, so an older class isn't favored for having had more seasons. A class's score is its picks' value above or below their slots; the letter grades it against the same draft's 32 classes (A about the top sixth, F the bottom sixth).

Value counts the whole career wherever it was played; "Kept" is the share earned for the drafting team. Trades of picks are credited to the team that made the pick. Recent classes keep moving as careers go on.